Shopify Custom App Development vs Public and Third-Party Apps

Shopify custom app development: private or public app vs using a third-party one

Every Shopify merchant reaches the same fork sooner or later. You can install an app someone else built. Or you can pay for Shopify custom app development and own the result. Both paths work, and the right one depends on your budget, your timeline and how unusual your workflow is.

This guide compares three options: custom apps, public apps and third-party apps from the Shopify App Store. It also covers what changed recently, because Shopify retired private apps and moved where custom apps get built.

Here is the short answer. Use an App Store app when one already does the job, because it is the fastest and cheapest start. Choose a custom app when the workflow is specific to your store, such as an ERP sync or custom checkout logic. Build a public app only when many merchants share the problem and you want to sell the fix. That is also how our Shopify app development team frames the choice for clients.

Install an Existing App or Build Your Own?

Four factors decide whether to install an App Store app or pay for Shopify custom app development. Weigh them in this order.

Cost comes first. A custom Shopify app takes real developer time, especially if your team has never shipped one. App Store apps, by contrast, usually charge a one-time or recurring fee.

Functionality is next. If no existing app meets your requirements, custom development may be the best option. Still, check the App Store first, because existing apps often include features you had not thought of.

Then consider maintenance. When you own an app, you also own its upkeep. Shopify releases a new API version every three months and supports each one for at least 12 months, per its API versioning docs. So someone has to keep your app current. If you lack that capacity, an App Store app is the more practical choice.

Finally, think about time to market. You can install an existing app the same day. A custom build takes longer, especially without a dedicated team.

How to vet a third-party app before you install it

If an App Store app looks like a fit, check it before you install it. First, read the reviews and ratings, and look at how recently the developer shipped an update. Then check which store data the app asks to access, because every permission is a risk you accept.

Next, measure speed. Install the app on a test theme and compare page load times, since apps that add storefront scripts can slow your pages. Also look for the Built for Shopify badge. Shopify grants that status only to apps that meet its standards for performance and ease of use. Finally, use the free trial, if there is one, to test the app against your real workflow.

Developing Your Own Custom Shopify Apps

Types of Shopify App Development

Types of Shopify app development: custom app development, white-label app development, app modification and customization

Shopify app development work falls into three types, and each one has its own trade-offs.

The first is Shopify custom app development. You build a Shopify app from scratch for one merchant, or for a few stores under one owner. It usually costs the most and takes the longest. In return, it fits the merchant’s exact needs. Shopify used to call these private apps.

The second is public, or white-label, app development. Here you build one app that many merchants install from the App Store, sometimes under your own brand. Because many stores share it, the cost per merchant drops.

The third is app modification. A developer adapts an existing app to one merchant’s needs. That is often the cheapest route when you need a specific change but don’t want to start from zero.

In short, custom development gives full control at the highest cost. Public apps spread the cost across many stores, and modification buys a targeted change for less.

Shopify Custom Apps vs Public Apps

Public Shopify apps serve many merchants. Merchants install them from the Shopify App Store, and most charge a subscription. Privy for email capture and pop-ups and Klaviyo for email marketing are two well-known examples. With a public app, you also get the developer’s support team and updates that you don’t pay for directly.

Custom apps serve a single merchant, and they don’t appear in the App Store. Shopify used to call them private apps. It deprecated private apps in January 2022 and converted the remaining ones to custom apps on January 20, 2023, according to its app distribution docs. The merchant or an outside developer can build one.

What changed for custom Shopify apps in 2026

One more change matters if you plan a build now. Since January 1, 2026, merchants can no longer create new custom apps inside the Shopify admin, as Shopify’s developer changelog notes. Instead, a developer builds the app in the Dev Dashboard and then installs it on the store. Existing admin-created apps keep working.

Here are the main differences between the two types:

Public appCustom app
Who can install itAny merchant, through the Shopify App StoreOne store, or several stores in the same Plus organization
Shopify reviewRequired before listingNot required
BillingUsually a subscription through ShopifyAgreed between merchant and developer
CustomizationBuilt for a wide audienceBuilt around one merchant’s workflow

So public apps are often the quick, low-cost answer. A custom app makes more sense when your needs are specific or your budget allows a build.

When to Make Your Shopify App Public vs Keep It Custom

When to white label your Shopify app to the public vs keeping your custom app private

Choosing between a public and a custom Shopify app is not always obvious, because each type has benefits and drawbacks. Here are four cases we have seen.

A fashion retailer wanted shoppers to design their own clothing and accessories and order them through an app. It built a public app and listed it in the Shopify App Store, where other merchants can install it too.

A jewelry company, one of our clients, wanted to streamline order processing and fulfillment. It built a custom app that connected Shopify to its internal systems and automated both steps. The app never went into the App Store, because only the jeweler used it.

A home decor company wanted shoppers to preview furniture and decor in their own rooms. For that, it built a public app that used augmented reality, and listed it in the App Store.

A clothing company wanted the same design-your-own feature as the fashion retailer. However, it built a custom app instead, because the feature only had to work in its own store.

As a software development company, we suggest a few questions before you decide. Should other stores be able to use the app? Do you plan to share or sell it? Will you need to extend it as the business grows? And how fast do you need support when something breaks?

How to Get a Public Shopify App Approved

Only public apps go through Shopify’s review, so these steps apply when you list an app in the App Store. Each one raises your odds of approval.

  1. Read Shopify’s App Store requirements and follow them. They cover policy, functionality, security and the app listing, plus extra rules for some app categories.
  2. Test the app thoroughly before you submit it, and confirm that it meets every requirement.
  3. Include clear documentation that explains how the app works and how it meets the requirements.
  4. Use high-quality graphics and branding. Your listing is the first thing merchants see, so make it look professional.
  5. Respond quickly to feedback. If Shopify rejects the app, read the notes, fix each issue and resubmit.

When Shopify Custom App Development Pays Off

Shopify custom app development suits merchants whose needs no public app can meet. Because the app serves only your store, you decide who uses it and what it does. Nobody else can install it, so a feature you paid for stays yours.

The strongest case is a link to your own systems. For example, a custom app can sync orders with an ERP, pull stock levels from a warehouse system or apply pricing rules that only your business has. Our guide to integrating third-party software into a Shopify Plus store covers that kind of work.

Custom apps are also where Plus stores now put checkout logic. Shopify Scripts stopped running on June 30, 2026, per Shopify’s Scripts changelog. Their replacement is Shopify Functions, which customize discount, shipping and payment logic. However, only Plus stores can run custom apps that contain Functions, according to the Functions docs. Stores on other plans can still use Functions through public apps.

A custom app is also easy to extend as you grow, since you and your developer add features when you need them. You also set the release schedule. Nobody else’s roadmap decides when a feature ships or disappears, which is a real risk with apps you rent. The trade-off is that you pay for that work and for the upkeep. If checkout logic is the reason you are looking at Plus, first check what Shopify Plus costs and includes.

When an App Store app is the better choice

Still, a custom app is the wrong choice for common jobs. Reviews, email capture, subscriptions and shipping labels already have mature apps with years of fixes behind them. Rebuilding one of those rarely pays off unless the gap blocks a workflow that makes you money.

Our ecommerce development team has delivered 100+ e-commerce projects. If you are unsure which path fits, we can help you compare an App Store app with a custom build before you spend on either.

The production-grade automation blueprint

Stop building fragile chatbots. Get the exact 5-phase blueprint we use to extract your team’s tribal knowledge and install durable, bank-grade AI systems that actually run.

Install the machine.
Stop renting the operator.

We don’t sell hours, headcount, or throwaway POCs. We install the agent-driven systems and automation infrastructure your business needs to scale.

Discuss your infrastructure directly with a senior engineer.

Scroll to top